That's Amore is a family owned and operated pizzeria that serves the best tasting stone-oven pizza, tasty appetizers, healthy specialty salads, and offers a full menu of authentic Italian dishes, all in our warm welcoming "That's Amore" ambiance. All of our food is made using our family's own recipes passed down for over three generations while using the finest and freshest ingredients.


That's Amore Pizzeria is proud to serve Bayport/Bluepoint and Sayville communities!


Feel free to browse our menu and call us up to place an order immediately. We are located at 881 Montauk hwy., Bayport, NY 11705 and can be reached at 631-868-7474.




Let us cater your parties for a holiday or any special event!

Click here or the menu below for more catering information